Examining the Christian County Library Timeline: A Documentary Analysis

The News-Leader and its journalism about Christian County Library is based on opinion and not fact. Here are some facts.

I wonder if Springfield News-Leader enjoys being wrong so often in their reporting.

Reviewing the Public Record

The Christian County Library Board controversy has generated significant public interest. This analysis presents a chronological review of documented events based on public records, meeting minutes, and published reports. Each claim is directly attributed to its source to allow readers to verify information independently.

The Documented Timeline: Key Events

August 27, 2024: Board Meeting Discussion

According to HickChristian's reporting dated September 9, 2024, during this board meeting, a discussion about book labeling occurred. The article states: "The Liberal board members brought it up and asked that the categories be 'LGBT' books... Janis Hagen is the one who proposes..." [1] The report indicates that the board only voted to research options, not to implement labeling. This characterization can be verified by reviewing the public meeting minutes [2].

October 11, 2024: Attorney Communication

Public records show that attorney Harry Styron sent a communication to the Board of Trustees regarding the Virden v. Crawford County, Arkansas decision. According to documentation cited in HickChristian, this communication included analysis suggesting that "placing labels on materials with LGBTQ themes or content would constitute unconstitutional viewpoint discrimination" [3]. This communication addressed the same type of labeling that had been discussed at the August meeting.

September 23-26, 2024: Legal Proceedings

Gretchen Garrity reported on September 27, 2024 that a lawsuit had been filed naming Janis Hagen and the Christian County Library District as plaintiffs against board members [4]. Public court records would confirm the filing of this lawsuit and its parties. Documentation referenced in HickChristian indicates that on September 26, 2024, there was a procedural motion regarding Hagen's status as plaintiff [5].

December 16, 2024: Financial Discussion

According to board meeting minutes from this date, there was a presentation of legal fees from Styron & Shilling, including fees outside the regular monthly retainer [6]. The minutes indicate that board members asked questions about these fees and authorization for the work.

Public Records Request Processing

Missouri law establishes a 3-business-day response timeline for Sunshine Law requests [7]. HickChristian has reported some delays in responses to public records requests while noting that certain information has appeared in other publications [8].

Documented Communications

The public record includes several noteworthy communications:

1. Email Communication (January 23, 2025): HickChristian has published documentation of an email in which board member Janis Hagen wrote: "And I am forwarding a message from Renee she sent to the new lawyer and Echo when she left. As always, I will follow your lead!" [9]

2. Personnel Changes: Public records show that Executive Director Renee Brumett submitted her resignation on December 17, 2024, which was the day after the board meeting where questions about legal fees were discussed [10].

3. Historical Meeting Minutes: Gretchen Garrity's reporting references board minutes from July 26, 2021 and July 25, 2023 showing officer elections conducted outside the month of December [11]. Her report states: "While officer elections are mandated in the bylaws for December, the bylaws do not specifically prohibit officer elections at other times of the year." [12]

4. Bylaw Amendment: According to public meeting minutes, the board voted on September 24, 2024 "to amend the bylaws to specifically state that officer elections can occur at any time of the year, as warranted." [13]

Relevant Legal and Procedural Context

For complete understanding of this situation, several legal and procedural contexts are worth noting:

1. Missouri Sunshine Law Requirements: Missouri law (RSMo 610.023.3) establishes that public bodies must respond to records requests within 3 business days [14].

2. Attorney-Client Relationships: The Missouri Rules of Professional Conduct provide guidance on attorneys' duties to clients and former clients. Rule 4-1.9 addresses duties to former clients and situations where conflicts may arise [15].

3. Board Governance Procedures: Public libraries in Missouri operate under Chapter 182 of the Missouri Revised Statutes, which establishes the legal framework for library governance [16].

Conclusion: The Value of Complete Information

When examining controversial situations involving public institutions, access to complete information serves the public interest. The Christian County Library situation underscores the importance of:

1. Reviewing primary source documents

2. Examining the full chronology of events

3. Consulting multiple perspectives

4. Verifying claims against the public record

Citizens benefit from having access to comprehensive information about public institutions. This documentary timeline provides context that helps community members understand the sequence of events and evaluate various interpretations of the situation.

---

References

[1] Rice, David. "State Media Lies About the Library, Part 1." HickChristian, September 9, 2024. https://hickchristian.substack.com/

[2] Christian County Library Board meeting minutes, August 27, 2024.

[3] Email communication referenced in HickChristian, October 11, 2024.

[4] Garrity, Gretchen. "Library Board Minutes Tell a Story." HickChristian, September 27, 2024. https://hickchristian.substack.com/p/library-board-minutes-tell-a-story

[5] Rice, David. "Loco Absentiae." HickChristian, September 25, 2024. https://hickchristian.substack.com/p/loco-absentiae

[6] Christian County Library Board meeting minutes, December 16, 2024.

[7] Missouri Revised Statutes, Chapter 610, Section 610.023.3.

[8] Rice, David. "Library Official Stonewalls Sunshine Requests While Sharing Information with Select Media." HickChristian, March 25, 2025. https://hickchristian.substack.com/

[9] Email communication referenced in HickChristian, January 23, 2025.

[10] Public announcement of Renee Brumett's resignation, December 17, 2024.

[11] Christian County Library Board meeting minutes, July 26, 2021 and July 25, 2023.

[12] Garrity, Gretchen. "Library Board Minutes Tell a Story." HickChristian, September 27, 2024. https://hickchristian.substack.com/p/library-board-minutes-tell-a-story

[13] Christian County Library Board meeting minutes, September 24, 2024.

[14] Missouri Revised Statutes, Chapter 610, Section 610.023.3.

[15] Missouri Rules of Professional Conduct, Rule 4-1.9.

[16] Missouri Revised Statutes, Chapter 182.